Customer Reviews

• 3.6

  Based on 49 Reviews

  Write a Review

  Pros

  Comfortable (8), Versatile (5), Stylish (7), Good Cushioning (4), Great with Jeans (6), Stable (1), Arch Support (1), Durable (1)

  Cons

  Stains Easily (1), Poor Support / Stability (2), Poor Fit (3), Poor Arch Support (1), Poor Cushioning (1), Uncomfortable (3), Too Stiff (2), Poor Quality (1), Wears Quickly (1)

  View On Shoes

  Shoes are for Wearing (1)

  Sizing

  Feels true to size (7), Feels full size too small (2), Feels half size too small (2)

  Best Uses

  Casual Wear (10), Travel (3), Dates / Night Out (2), Work (4), School (2)

  Width

  Feels true to width (10)

  Describe Yourself

  Stylish (5), Trendy Style (2), Conservative (3)

• Reviewed by 49 customers

  Displaying reviews 1 - 49

  Sort By Newest Oldest Highest rating Lowest rating Most Helpful Least Helpful

• 7/3/17

  3.0
  Better quality back then, sizing was off

  by Zoe from Texas

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I bought my first pair about 7 years ago, I wore them until they fell apart! They were super comfortable and the cushioning was great up until the last day. I bought a new pair of the same shoe recently in the same size but it didn't fit at all! The nearest lucky store is 4 hours away so I had to pay to return them. Also, cushioning was much smaller and the left shoe was really curled in from the elastic and right shoe was nearly flat. Not sure what happened to the quality, it was an amazing shoe.

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 6/27/17

  1.0
  inconsistent fit

  by Disappointed Debbie from Newport Beach, CA

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I have a pair of these shoes that are well worn. I've enjoyed them so much that I ordered 2 colors of the exact same size of this flat. They came today and I was so disappointed. One size fit and the other I could barely get my feet into. I laid the 2 colors of the same shoe side by side and they literally looked like they were at least 2 sizes different from each other. So now I either have to pay $8.00 to return the one that doesn't fit or take my time to go to the store, which I don't like to do and is why I buy online in the first place. Something is wrong in the quality control department.

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 6/19/17

  (6 of 6 customers found this review helpful)
  1.0
  Shorter, Smaller and CHEAPER

  by Sophie Katt from San Antonio, TX

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  As time goes by, the Emmie Leather Ballet Flat just gets shorter and smaller and CHEAPER - I started out wearing an 8.5. Three years later, I'm up to a 9.5, now tell me: Did my feet grow that much?!? NO. Lucky Brand is making the Emmie Leather Ballet Flat even more CHEAPLY than ever! The sole used to be thicker, the leather used to be a better quality, and they used to be sized CORRECTLY. I'm NEVER buying another pair, this stinks!! STOP BEING SO CHEAP AND MAKE A DECENT, CORRECTLY SIZED PAIR OF SHOES, SHEESH!!!

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 5/8/17

  5.0
  So cute!

  by tiny_espichan from Springfield,VA

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I have the nude flats & now these, they're really cute, go with almost everything in my closet. I can't wait to wear them :)

  Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 3/23/17

  (2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
  5.0
  I freaking love these flats

  by Gourmay from Detroit, MI

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I can't find one of my shoes and I'm forced to buy another pair. They're soooooo comfy! I feel like I'm walking on sunshine!

  Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 3/20/17

  (2 of 5 customers found this review helpful)
  1.0
  Worst flats ever

  by Tieks Lover from Advance NC

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I may be biased cause I'm a Tieks person, but these were terrible! I bought the blue sueded ones and can't wear them longer than 5 minutes.

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 3/7/17

  (3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
  5.0
  Best flat there is!

  by Elizabeth from New York, NY

  Pros

  Comfortable, Versatile, Stable, Arch Support, Good Cushioning, Durable, Great with Jeans

  Sizing

  Feels true to size

  Best Uses

  Casual Wear

  Width

  Feels true to width

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  The Emmie flats are the best flats around. I'm shocked to see some people found them uncomfortable, especially people saying they don't have room for their toes. I have super odd shaped feet and kind of big toes and I have no problems like that with these shoes. They fit great, they don't dig into the big toe, the side of my foot, or the back of my heel at all. I also have really high arches and so many flats are so low that my foot is basically higher than the shoe. This shoe allows me to actually walk in them. Someone commented that the shoe doesn't lie flat if you put it on the ground - but that's exactly why it's comfortable! it's flexible so it works with your foot instead of being stiff. A shoe that lays flat would dig into the top of your foot when you walk, and provide no support as you stand. The emmie flat has perfect cushioning and offers support all day no matter how much standing or walking.

  Age

  35 to 44

  Gender

  Female

  Body type

  Petite

  Height

  5'5"

  Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 12/15/16

  (4 of 5 customers found this review helpful)
  1.0
  Terrible Shoe

  by LucyJane from Texas

  Pros

  Stylish, Great with Jeans

  Cons

  Presses on the big toes like a vice!, Poor Support / Stability, Poor Fit, Poor Arch Support, Poor Cushioning, Uncomfortable

  Sizing

  Feels true to size

  Best Uses

  Casual Wear, Travel, School

  Width

  Feels true to width

  Describe Yourself

  Stylish

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  These shoes are so cute! Too bad they are designed for people without big toes. Seriously. They press on the big toes and I bough a wide width even though my feet are narrow just to avoid all of the trouble that I read about in other reviews. Soooo, it's like designing a bra with no room for breasts. If they redesign this shoe so that it actually accommodates the big toes of the feet (or if I lose my big toes in some sort of farming incident, I will buy them again. They are so cute! So sad.

  Age

  45 to 54

  Gender

  Female

  Body type

  Petite

  Height

  5'2"

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 12/4/16

  (2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
  4.0
  I have 3 pairs!

  by Katelyn from Nashville, TN

  Pros

  Comfortable, Versatile, Good Cushioning, Great with Jeans

  Cons

  Stains Easily

  Sizing

  Feels true to size

  Best Uses

  Casual Wear, Travel, Work, Dates / Night Out, School

  Width

  Feels true to width

  Describe Yourself

  Conservative

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I am a teacher and I can wear these all day! I bought the brown pari first, then black, then nude. I am hoping to buy another pair because I love the fit and how they look with jeans and dresses. The only downside is the that they are worn because I wear them so much.

  Age

  25 to 34

  Gender

  Female

  Body type

  I'd prefer not to say

  Height

  5'2"

  Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 10/26/16

  1.0
  Looks Good but Not Comfortable

  by Jen from Georgia

  Pros

  Stylish

  Cons

  Too Stiff, Poor Fit, Uncomfortable

  Sizing

  Feels full size too small

  Best Uses

  Casual Wear

  Describe Yourself

  Trendy Style

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  Feels as if the top of the shoe is drawn together like a very tight draw string!!! If you lay the shoe down, it will not even lay flat on the floor but curls. It is terribly painful to wear. Unbearable!

  Age

  18 to 24

  Gender

  Female

  Body type

  Petite

  Height

  5'2"

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• Displaying reviews 1 - 49 Back to Top