Customer Reviews

• 3.6

  Based on 57 Reviews

  Write a Review

  Pros

  Comfortable (8), Stylish (7), Great with Jeans (6), Versatile (5), Good Cushioning (4), Stable (1), Arch Support (1), Durable (1)

  Cons

  Poor Support / Stability (2), Poor Fit (3), Poor Arch Support (1), Poor Cushioning (1), Uncomfortable (3), Poor Quality (1), Wears Quickly (1), Stains Easily (1), Too Stiff (2)

  View On Shoes

  Shoes are for Wearing (1)

  Sizing

  Feels true to size (7), Feels half size too small (2), Feels full size too small (2)

  Best Uses

  Casual Wear (10), Travel (3), School (2), Dates / Night Out (2), Work (4)

  Width

  Feels true to width (10)

  Describe Yourself

  Stylish (5), Trendy Style (2), Conservative (3)

• Reviewed by 57 customers

  Displaying reviews 1 - 57

  Sort By Newest Oldest Highest rating Lowest rating Most Helpful Least Helpful

• 10/7/17

  5.0
  Looking to buy my second pair in a different color

  by Pedess from Tampa, FL

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I have had my Bourbon colored Emmies for over a year. I wear them with business casual, dress up, and casual wear. They are comfortable, true to the size I usually wear, and really cute. The leather stands up to water spots, which is always something I appreciate, and they are not looking bad after wearing them a year.

  Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 9/23/17

  1.0
  Loved the shoes until they got a hole after 3 months :(

  by Poppy from Michigan

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I bought these flats in June for my new office job. I wear them exclusively to work spending most of the day sitting at a desk but do walk around the hospital some. Less than three months after purchase the left shoe has a split on the seam next to the sole. I expect shoes to last longer than 3 months especially when I am spending the majority of the day sitting down.

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 9/11/17

  5.0
  Best flats I never had...

  by Teddybear from New Jersey

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  Best best flat. I ordered 6 pairs of this design, orange, brown... they are really comfortable and looks great.

  Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 9/8/17

  (3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
  1.0
  Do not buy.

  by Sgriffin from Alabama

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I have owned 3 different pairs hoping to have different results but they wear quickly . Like after 4 wears the side stitching is already coming apart as did on every paid I've had which stinks for price.

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 8/20/17

  (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
  3.0
  Comfy but not structured

  by Tues from Minneapolis, MN

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  They're very cushioned, which is comfortable. However, it's all cushion - on the sides, the front, the back, everywhere. I wish they were more structured around the foot but the sole would stay cushiony. Because they're cushioned all over, I feel like it looks wider than it really is, like a pillow around my foot.

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 8/16/17

  (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
  5.0
  Fell in love with first step!

  by cairndiggs from Apollo Beach

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  True to size. Comfortable for aching feet. Stylish colors that go with everything, everywhere. Dressy or casual wear...will try to collect as many colors as possible...on sale! Thank you! Been looking for comfortable flats, no need to look further. Signed...your newest fan!

  Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 8/8/17

  (2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
  4.0
  Comfort doesn't really last throughout the day

  by Bri the Hopeful from Los Angeles, CA

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  Four stars because I have hope that my flats will get better! I wore them around the house and the back of my foot hurt a little, but I thought I was just being too picky. So I went to work in them (retail, so lots of standing and walking), and at the end of the day, my feet really hurt. I had to just force myself to withstand the pain (mostly the edges of my foot, towards the toes). I took them off for a few seconds and put them back on to find them not as painful after that quick break. Hopefully I just need to break these in more, I've only had them for a day. And I'm not giving up on my flats!! Emmies, you will be my friend!

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 7/21/17

  (4 of 4 customers found this review helpful)
  5.0
  THE BEST SHOES I HAVE EVER OWNED.

  by Chilli from Calgary, Canada

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  From work, to the strip in Vegas, these shoes are my partner for every thing! I wish they had them in 50 fabrics, I'd start a collection. They fold easily to slip into your purse and they are so incredibly comfortable. They fit your feet just as nicely when they are a bit on the puffy side of the month and never pinch. I always look for them when I go to the states - I can't say enough great things about them.

  Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 7/3/17

  (5 of 5 customers found this review helpful)
  3.0
  Better quality back then, sizing was off

  by Zoe from Texas

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I bought my first pair about 7 years ago, I wore them until they fell apart! They were super comfortable and the cushioning was great up until the last day. I bought a new pair of the same shoe recently in the same size but it didn't fit at all! The nearest lucky store is 4 hours away so I had to pay to return them. Also, cushioning was much smaller and the left shoe was really curled in from the elastic and right shoe was nearly flat. Not sure what happened to the quality, it was an amazing shoe.

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• 6/27/17

  (7 of 7 customers found this review helpful)
  1.0
  inconsistent fit

  by Disappointed Debbie from Newport Beach, CA

  Comments about Lucky Emmie Flats

  I have a pair of these shoes that are well worn. I've enjoyed them so much that I ordered 2 colors of the exact same size of this flat. They came today and I was so disappointed. One size fit and the other I could barely get my feet into. I laid the 2 colors of the same shoe side by side and they literally looked like they were at least 2 sizes different from each other. So now I either have to pay $8.00 to return the one that doesn't fit or take my time to go to the store, which I don't like to do and is why I buy online in the first place. Something is wrong in the quality control department.

  Bottom Line No, I would not recommend this to a friend.

  Was this review helpful? Yes / No  - You may also flag this review

• Displaying reviews 1 - 57 Back to Top